The Retention Challenge in iGaming

Retention

Why talent leaves, what keeps them, and the job hopping dilemma
Employee retention has become one of the defining challenges facing the iGaming industry. In a sector where talent is the primary competitive advantage, the constant churn of skilled professionals threatens innovation, operational stability, and long-term growth.
To understand why talent leaves, what keeps them, and how to navigate the job hopping dilemma, we spoke with over ten hiring managers, executives, and industry veterans, with more than 150 years of combined experience, across our Career Conversations series. Their insights reveal that retention is rarely about one factor alone, and job hopping, when done with intent, is often a rational response to stalled growth rather than a lack of loyalty.

Why people leave: the honest truth

Money talks, especially early on

Let’s address the elephant in the room…compensation matters. When asked directly what factors made him consider moving jobs, Robert Camilleri, a BI Expert with over 13 years in the industry, didn’t sugarcoat it:

“Salary is always a big one, right? Unfortunately, I think sometimes we try to kid ourselves as if we don’t work for money, but we do.”

This is especially true for junior data analyst professionals. Robert Camilleri has seen it firsthand with analysts on his team: “It’s not unusual to be offered a 30% or 40% salary increase as soon as you make it out of the junior stage.” That’s a common way to lose someone…

His advice to employers is to make sure the initial pay is competitive because playing catch-up with counteroffers is often a losing game.

The remote work divide

Since COVID, flexibility has shifted from a perk to a baseline expectation for many professionals. The ability to work remotely, or at least in a hybrid setup, now plays a decisive role in whether people stay or start looking elsewhere. As more companies push for a return to the office, some employees are choosing to walk away. And as more companies push for a return to the office, some employees are walking out the door.

For Jacqui Gatt, who worked fully remote as COO at BeyondPlay (later acquired by FanDuel), the benefits are clear:

“I’m all in for working remote.”

The flexibility allowed her to be present when her children came home from school while still delivering in a demanding startup environment. In her view, the industry has largely moved on from the expectation of full-time office attendance, with most professionals now favouring remote or hybrid models.

But there is a trade-off that ambitious professionals should consider. Benedict McDonagh, Director of Studios at Entain with 19 years of industry experience, warns that career progression can become harder when visibility drops:

“The corridor conversations, working on your own profile and awareness, that’s a big drawback. Getting people to understand who you are and what contribution you bring is certainly made a lot harder when you work remotely.”

Nadiya Attard, Chief Commercial Officer at Elantil with 20+ years’ experience, takes an even firmer stance, particularly when it comes to commercial roles. She believes sales and business development teams benefit significantly from being physically together, where learning, momentum, and collaboration happen more naturally:

“If you want to progress, if you’re ambitious, if you want to grow, the only place where you learn how to do things is in the office.”

Her view isn’t anti-flexibility, but pragmatic: a balanced model, typically two to three days in the office, offers structure without sacrificing autonomy.

The tension is real. Employees want flexibility, but visibility still matters for advancement. Companies enforcing a full return to office risk losing experienced talent, while professionals insisting on fully remote work may unintentionally limit their growth. In practice, the winners are those who find the right balance for their role, ambition, and stage of life.

Beyond the paycheck

While a significant raise might lure talent away, it’s often a deficit in growth, challenge, or culture that made them look in the first place. Competitive pay gets you in the game but these factors determine whether you win. Robert points to room for growth, meaningful challenges, and working relationships as key drivers.

Do employees get on with management? Do they connect with their peers? These factors matter enormously.

James Pacheco, a content writer with over two decades of experience, left corporate life entirely after growing exhausted by the endless cycle of targets, all-hands meetings, and office pressures. Burnout is real, and even loyal employees have limits.

What employers can do to keep talent

Create ownership and growth paths

Thomas Mahoney, an Operations and HR specialist who pioneered employer branding at Tipico, believes the secret to retention lies in meaningful work. He actively seeks out people with passion, drive, and an entrepreneurial streak, and contrary to what some might assume, he doesn’t consider them flight risks. Give ambitious people ownership, responsibility, and a clear path for growth, and they’ll become your strongest advocates rather than your biggest attrition risk.

Foster internal mobility

Benedict McDonagh, is living proof of what internal mobility can achieve. At Betfair, he held “eight different job titles in nine years”, moving from customer service to management to product development. That culture of affording colleagues opportunities for growth became, in his words, the best learning ground he could have hoped for. When employees can grow without leaving, they don’t need to look elsewhere.

Invest in company culture

Christine Parkhill, Chief Commercial Officer at Just Slots, emphasises that culture isn’t a nice-to-have, it’s foundational. Benedict McDonagh agrees, noting that good working environments directly translate to better products and happier customers. The companies that treat culture as a strategic priority, not an HR checkbox, are the ones that retain their best people.

The job hopper dilemma: both sides of the story

The true cost when hires don’t work out

Before understanding why employers scrutinise job hoppers, it’s worth appreciating what’s at stake. Every hiring decision represents a significant investment, and when it doesn’t work out, the losses are substantial.

Nadiya Attard, puts it bluntly:

“It takes so much time to bring somebody in, your time to invest. Six months before the person will start delivering and performing.”

She’s learned the hard way not to hire the wrong person just to fill a gap quickly. Research from Gallup confirms the scale of this investment: replacing a single employee can cost anywhere from 50% to 200% of their annual salary, depending on seniority. Entry-level positions cost around half the employee’s annual salary to replace; senior executives can cost double or more. These figures account for recruitment, onboarding, lost productivity, and the time it takes new hires to reach full effectiveness.

This is why hiring managers in iGaming, where specialised knowledge and relationships matter enormously, are particularly cautious about candidates who might not stay.

How iGaming’s early days shaped today’s hiring culture

Diagnosing the root causes of today’s retention challenges requires an understanding of the iGaming industry’s unique evolution. In its early, largely unregulated growth phase, Malta emerged as a central hub for talent as one of the first jurisdictions to regulate the sector. During this period, recruitment messaging often leaned heavily on lifestyle appeal rather than professional rigor. The emphasis on sun, speed, and perks attracted a workforce that, in some cases, prioritised lifestyle over long-term craft, contribution, or industry expertise.

This dynamic, combined with rapid company growth and readily available capital, contributed to inflated salaries and accelerated career progression. In a market where profitability was widespread, it became easier for weak organisational habits to go unnoticed and harder to distinguish between genuinely well-run companies and those benefitting from favourable conditions.

As a result, some professionals advanced by moving frequently between organisations, gaining titles and compensation without always developing deep, role-specific capability.

As regulation increased and market conditions tightened, these structural weaknesses were exposed. Companies were forced to mature operationally, and hiring leaders became more cautious, particularly around short tenures. This shift reflects experience, as misalignment between role, capability, and expectation is costly for both employers and employees.

The legacy of this early phase still shapes today’s hiring environment. Historical patterns of rapid movement and inflated expectations have contributed to a more sceptical approach to retention and recruitment, reinforcing the need for clearer growth paths, stronger management practices, and better alignment between opportunity and readiness.

Why employers are wary of job hoppers

Given these stakes, it’s no surprise that frequent job changes raise eyebrows. Robert Camilleri admits he’s wary of candidates who spend just a few months in each role, one short stint might be explainable, but a pattern of three or four raises serious questions.

Nadiya Attard is direct about what she considers a “big red flag”: someone spending seven or eight months at one company, then a year at another, in never-ending cycles. Her benchmark? Two years is acceptable; over three years is much better.

Benedict McDonagh looks for evidence of progression. He’d rather see someone who entered at one level and grew within the same company than someone who’s held the same role at three different organisations, which suggests they’re chasing salary bumps rather than genuine development.

Why manager conversations matter

Here’s the encouraging news, much of this turnover is preventable. The same Gallup research found that 52% of voluntarily exiting employees say their manager or organisation could have done something to prevent them from leaving. Nadiya Attard has seen this play out firsthand. She’s noticed that many managers avoid one-to-ones, treating them as an HR obligation rather than a retention tool. But in her experience, “90 or 95% of people needed one-to-ones. It was so important to them.” It doesn’t need to be weekly, bi-weekly or monthly works. But people need dedicated time with their manager.

The managers who retain talent are the ones who make time to listen.

Why job seekers move

While employer caution is understandable, the best talent won’t stay in dead-end roles forever. Benedict McDonagh’s advice cuts both ways: “Go where you’re appreciated. You’ve got to enjoy what you do.” When you’ve hit the ceiling and can’t progress further, moving makes sense, as long as you have a solid rationale.

Jacqui Gatt, offers a memorable rule: “Don’t move sideways, move upwards.” She cautions against chasing salary alone, she’s seen people accelerate too fast, only to find themselves overwhelmed by responsibilities they weren’t ready for. Strategic patience often beats impulsive jumping.

And sometimes, leaving is simply the right call. Robert Camilleri acknowledges that if you’re not getting cooperation from your manager, that’s a legitimate reason to move on.

The bottom line

Retention in iGaming is about creating environments where talented people want to stay and grow. For employers, competitive salaries get you in the game, but ownership, clear growth paths, internal mobility, and genuine culture are what keep people engaged. Make time for meaningful one-to-ones; over half of exits are preventable through better manager conversations. The cost of losing good people far outweighs the investment required to keep them.

For jobseekers, the message is equally clear: be strategic about your moves. Go where you’re appreciated, but ensure each step is upward, not just a sideways move for a pay bump. Patterns of short tenures will raise questions, and employers have good reason to ask them.

In today’s hiring market, where many highly experienced professionals face longer job searches than usual, retention isn’t about locking people in. It’s about earning commitment through trust, growth, and opportunity.

These insights come directly from ongoing conversations with industry professionals through our Career Conversations series.

In the end, retention is a two-way street, and both sides need to hold up their end of the bargain.